Cancer Prevention Coalition CHICAGO, IL, September 30, 2009 --/WORLD-WIRE/-- You've probably used it, or had it sprinkled on you at some time in your life. It's processed from a soft mineral compound of magnesium silicate and is called talcum powder, or just talc.
Talcum powder is manufactured by Johnson & Johnson, among others,
and is widely available in drug stores. Women have been persuaded by
years of advertisements to dust themselves with talcum powder to mask
alleged genital odors.
While the powder has been a symbol of freshness and cleanliness for
over five decades, genital talc dusting is a dangerous, but avoidable,
cause of ovarian cancer, warns Dr. Samuel S. Epstein, chairman of the
Cancer Prevention Coalition.
The first warning of the dangers of genital talc dusting came in a 1971
report on the identification of talc particles in ovarian cancers, a
finding sharply contested by Dr. G.Y. Hildick-Smith, who was then
Johnson & Johnson's medical director.
A subsequent publication in the prestigious medical journal The Lancet
warned that, "The potentially harmful effects of talc ... in the ovary
... should not be ignored." This warning was confirmed in a 1992
article in the journal Obstetrics & Gynecology which reported that
a woman's frequent talc use on her genitals increased her risk of
ovarian cancer by threefold. The talc in question was simple brand or
generic "baby powder."
After the 1992 report, at least a dozen other major scientific articles
documenting the link between talc and ovarian cancer appeared in
leading medical journals such as Cancer, The Lancet, and Oncology. The
capstone of this research against talc came in 2003 when the journal
Anticancer Research published a 'meta-analysis,' or large scale review,
of 16 previous published studies involving 11,933 women. A 33 percent
increased risk of ovarian cancer was confirmed, Dr. Epstein points out.
"Not surprisingly," says Dr. Epstein, "the mortality of ovarian cancer
in women 65 years of age and older has escalated sharply, especially in
black women who have a higher rate of talc use than other races."
Nearly 16,000 women in the U.S. die from ovarian cancer each year,
which means it is the fourth most common fatal cancer in women. By some
estimates, one out of five women regularly applies talc to her
genitals. This usage occurs either through direct application, or as a
result of tampons, sanitary pads and diaphragms that have been dusted
with talc, Dr. Epstein points out.
More acknowledgment of talc's dangers emerged, even from the cosmetics
industry. The president of the industry's Cosmetic Toiletry and
Fragrance Association, Edward Kavanaugh, conceded in 2002 that talc is
toxic and "can reach the human ovaries."
Yet, says Dr. Epstein, "inexplicably, talc manufacturers failed to warn
women that the product could be dangerous to their health."
Nor has the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) shown even casual
concern about the dangers of talc. The closest admission to this effect
came in 1993 when the acting associate commissioner for legislative
affairs of the Department of Health and Human Services admitted, "We
are aware that there have been reports in the medical literature
between frequent female perineal talc dusting over a protracted period
of years, and an incremental increase in the statistical odds of
subsequent development of certain ovarian cancers."
Dr. Epstein says he was amazed when this official went on to say the
FDA "is not considering to ban, restrict or require a warning statement
on the label of talc containing products." Aware of talc's extreme
dangers and alarmed by continued governmental unresponsiveness, in 1994
the Cancer Prevention Coalition, supported by the New York Center for
Constitutional Rights, submitted a Citizen's Petition to the FDA.
This petition requested that talc genital dusting powder be labeled
with an explicit warning of the major risks of ovarian cancer. However,
says Dr. Epstein, the FDA denied the petition. In May 2008, the Cancer
Prevention Coalition submitted another Citizen's Petition to the FDA.
This one was endorsed by a range of groups including the Organic
Consumers Association, the International Association for Humanitarian
Medicine, and Dr. Faye Williams of the National Congress of Black Women.
"We cited new scientific evidence on the dangers of talc, and requested
the FDA to mandate that all talc products be labeled with this type of
warning: "Frequent application of talcum powder in the female genital
area substantially increases the risk of ovarian cancer," Dr. Epstein
says.
However, Andrew von Eschenbach, M.D., then Commissioner of the FDA, failed to respond to this petition.
It is anticipated that Margaret Hamburg, M.D., the highly respected new
FDA Commissioner, will take prompt regulatory action to protect
unsuspecting women from the extreme dangers of talc.
Samuel S. Epstein, M.D. is professor emeritus of Environmental and
Occupational Medicine at the University of Illinois at Chicago School
of Public Health; Chairman of the Cancer Prevention Coalition; The
Albert Schweitzer Golden Grand Medalist for International Contributions
to Cancer Prevention; and author of over 200 scientific articles and 15
books on the causes and prevention of cancer, including the
groundbreaking The Politics of Cancer (1979), and Toxic Beauty (2009).
CONTACT:
Samuel S. Epstein, M.D.
Chairman,
Cancer Prevention Coalition
Professor emeritus
Environmental & Occupational Medicine
University of Illinois at Chicago School of Public Health
Chicago, Illinois
Tel: 312-996-2297
Email:
This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it
|